top of page

Neither Black nor White: The Forgotten History of Chinese Americans in the Jim Crow South 

Image by Stephen yu

Chongxin Huang

2024 Historical Paper

How does the increased level of people awareness on sustainable consumption impact the success of greenwashing strategies?

Process Paper 

Since Chinese Americans constitute a less-known but important component of American racial history, I decided to investigate their past in the Mississippi Delta. Examining how Chinese immigrants negotiated their conflicted position in the Jim Crow South, a system meant to maintain a rigid Black-and- white racial separation, this topic fits the theme of 2025 National History Day, "Rights & Responsibilities in History." While their employment as traders and commercial middlemen underscores the obligations they assumed in a segregated society, their quest to guarantee education, economic stability, and legal recognition emphasizes their fight for rights. Examining their experience will help me to highlight how underprivileged groups have negotiated systematic exclusion and changed to fit hostile surroundings. 

To build a general knowledge of Chinese immigration, segregation laws, and economic adaptability, my study started with compiling secondary sources—books, journal articles, and dissertations. While court cases like Gong Lum v. Rice (1927) offered insight into educational segregation, I looked to scholarly publications like Jung (2008) and Takaki (2012) to study migration trends. Court records, historical newspapers, and census data among other primary sources assisted me to grasp the legal and societal obstacles Chinese Americans encountered. Oral histories provide first-hand accounts of how individuals negotiated racial exclusion and created their communities. 

I organized my work to offer a thorough examination of Chinese Americans' hardships and resiliency in the Mississippi Delta. I first gave historical background, including their migration and first employment duties. I next looked at social and legal hurdles including economic constraints and school segregation. My investigation looked at how they set up community networks and grocery stores as a survival tactic. Finally, I examined how their racial classification changed over time and their changing interactions with Black and White populations. Historical data strongly supports my case; thus, I made sure my work complied with NHD rules including a clear thesis, citations, and a bibliography. 

According to my paper, Chinese Americans living in the Mississippi Delta had to negotiate both legal exclusion and economic opportunity while being caught between the strict racial system of the Jim Crow South. Chinese immigrants settled in a difficult middle ground unlike white Americans, who profited from institutional privileges, and African Americans, who confronted direct segregationist practices. Their growing alignment with white groups over time strained their earlier links with Black communities, even as they battled for education and economic rights. 

This history exposes the complexity of racial classification in America and questions the conventional Black-and- white myth of segregation. Their battles for social mobility, financial success, and education help one to see how historically ethnic minorities have negotiated exclusive regimes. Studying their stories helps us to understand how underprivileged groups battle for acknowledgment in a society that usually ignores them. 

 

Neither Black nor White: The Forgotten History of Chinese Americans in the Jim Crow South 

Introduction: 

The Mississippi Delta became an unplanned crossroads for Chinese immigration in the aftermath of the Reconstruction era, which added a new layer to the region's already established racial dynamics within the region. The Chinese minority in the Delta occupied a separate place inside this divide, which symbolized both the potential and restrictions of their ambiguous socioeconomic standing. This is in contrast to the traditional black-and-white binary of segregation, which is a binary that is often used. As a result of their position as intermediaries, the Chinese people of the Delta were able to better grasp their rights and obligations within a community that was highly divided. This research study investigates how they utilized their position, giving a complex exploration of how Chinese Americans in the segregated South claimed their rights and negotiated their responsibilities within a racially stratified society. 

In spite of the fact that these immigrants initially arrived as workers and later as merchants, segregationist laws that were founded on a binary racial hierarchy failed to recognize or accept them during their arrival. A comprehensive analysis of the economic and social practices of Chinese Americans is presented in Loewen (1988). This analysis sheds light on the ways in which Chinese Americans adapted to Jim Crow laws that were designed to exclude them and covertly fought against these laws. Their experiences offer a nuanced perspective on segregation, highlighting the struggle for identity and acceptance in a society that is deeply divided. Not only does this narrative deepen our comprehension of the complex history of racial discrimination in the United States, but it also sheds light on the tenacity and inventiveness of the Chinese minority in the face of institutionalized prejudice. 

Background and Historical Context: 

Given the region's long and illustrious history in the years following the Civil War, the arrival of Chinese people in the Mississippi Delta during the latter half of the 19th century and the early 20th century was a phenomena that came as a surprise. The economic opportunities that came from the burgeoning agricultural sector of the delta, particularly cotton, which required a huge work force after slavery was abolished, were the key motivators for this relocation. Cotton was particularly important among these prospects. Planters in the South resorted to Chinese laborers as a docile substitute when African American workers sought more wages and safer working conditions (Takaki, 2012). This was done in response to the demands of the workers. 

When Chinese people moved to the Delta, they brought with them the hope that they would have a better life back in China. Many of them had the intention of staying in this country for only a short period of time, with the ultimate objective of pursuing the American dream and retiring in China. However, the economic and social milieu in which they found themselves was 

 

characterized by stringent racial segregation regulations that had not been designed to accommodate the inclusion of a minority that was neither white nor black into the binary system of race that was already in place (Chang, 2004). As a result of the fact that they did not belong to either the privileged white class or the downtrodden Black class, the Chinese found themselves in an awkward position within the social structure of the local community. Despite the fact that they were disadvantaged due to a social divide, they were able to take advantage of particular opportunities (McLemore, 1980). 

The changing role of the Chinese population in the Delta was a reflection of larger changes in American labor and immigration policy, which had an increasing impact on their movements of integration and settlement. In an environment where racial tensions were prevalent, the Chinese were able to forge a community and survive the complexity of Jim Crow laws by establishing themselves as vendors and merchants (Jung, 2008). 

Challenges of Segregation: 

Southern racial segregation policies, such as Jim Crow, were a major factor in the difficulties experienced by Chinese Americans in the Mississippi Delta. The Chinese American community faced distinct social and economic challenges as a result of these rules, which classified them as neither white nor black. The fact that they were neither completely welcomed into "colored" regions nor "whites-only" public spaces and institutions put them in a liminal position within the racial hierarchy (Lee, 2015). 

As a result of segregation restrictions, Chinese youngsters encountered substantial obstacles in their educational pursuits. The group either had to start its own schools or stop sending its members to mainstream schools because they were often not allowed to attend white children's schools. The legal precedents that upheld the segregation of Chinese children from white schools denied them the same educational chances as their white classmates and further cemented the segregation (Dong, 2021). 

Additionally, segregation greatly limited the economic opportunities available to Chinese Americans. Discriminatory actions, such as denying them business permits or limiting their operations to certain areas, were commonplace for them. In addition to being economically marginalized, they faced social isolation due to the prevalence of racial prejudice and violence, which further impeded their success (Yang, 2021). 

The Chinese Americans who lived in the Delta demonstrated an extraordinary level of tenacity and inventiveness in spite of everything that occurred. Torok (2005) states that despite the fact that these individuals were subjected to structural exclusion, they were able to maintain their cultural identity and provide support for one another. This was accomplished through the establishment of networks and strategies that enabled them to negotiate and occasionally avoid the intense reality of segregation. 

 

Community Adaptation Strategies: 

As a result of racial exclusion and strict segregation laws, Chinese Americans in the Mississippi Delta came up with a variety of adaptation tactics to establish their own economic and social niches. The opening of grocery stores owned by Chinese people was a crucial part of these changes. These shops served as social centers for the larger African American community as well as the Chinese community, providing food and other necessities. The Chinese American community was able to forge ties and achieve economic autonomy by establishing itself as a vital service provider (Yu, 2022). 

Community adaptability was also greatly influenced by education. Private mission schools were set up by the Chinese community in response to the difficulties in enrolling in public schools. These schools provided a curriculum that blended conventional American education with Chinese language and cultural instruction. In order to preserve cultural history and guarantee community cohesiveness, these schools played a crucial role (Reynolds, 2023). 

Furthermore, Chinese Americans embraced a policy of active citizenship, frequently taking part in community groups and gatherings to raise their profile and advance socially. As a result of their participation, prejudices were weakened and a more complex view of their community's place in society was advanced (Gillot-Assayag,, 2016). 

Relations with Black and White Communities: 

As members of the Mississippi Delta's multi-ethnic community, Chinese Americans were well positioned to mediate between the region's Black and white populations. An important economic intermediary within the Delta's mostly multiracial society, many Chinese immigrants were hired as laborers to replace emancipated African Americans. Later, they shifted to managing food businesses that mostly served Black clients (Cheng, 1974). 

The Chinese American community and the Black community were able to thrive in this economic niche. Black communities and Chinese grocery stores grew economically interdependent because of the Chinese grocery stores' provision of necessities (Banks, 1998). Chinese Americans were subjected to the same forms of discrimination as African Americans due to their closeness; they were frequently denied admission to white institutions and categorized as "colored" (Loewen, 1971). 

Chinese Americans gradually aspired to rise in the social hierarchy by assimilation into white society. This shift entailed assimilating into white culture by embracing white cultural practices and social standards (Banks, 1998). This reflected the changing position of Chinese children in the racial hierarchy, as they were able to attend schools attended by white students (Shin, 2014). 

 

A separation from the Black community was a common consequence of this upward mobility, though. The complicated dynamics of race and class in the Delta were reflected in the increasingly complex relationships between Chinese Americans and their Black neighbors as they assimilated into white culture. This shift highlights how racial categories can change over time and how oppressed people use adaptation as a strategy to overcome repressive institutions (Loewen, 1988). 

As they skillfully maneuvered through their intermediary status, Chinese Americans in the Mississippi Delta established business links with Black communities and assimilated into white culture over time. Their stories illustrate the intricacies of racial relations in the American South and the tactics used by marginalized communities to navigate an oppressive social order. 

Conclusion: 

Chinese Americans' experiences in the Mississippi Delta called into question long-held notions about the causes of Southern racial segregation. Chinese communities, in contrast to white and black groups, were on a different rung of a tight racial hierarchy, subject to institutionalized prejudice but carving out opportunities for economic and social progress. Their progress from plantation laborers to business owners shows their control over their own lives and the constraints imposed by segregation. 

Despite being legally labeled as "colored" and socially barred from many aspects of white culture, Chinese Americans achieved success. They made a home for themselves in a culture that was not totally welcoming of them through economic ventures, educational adaptation, and intentional community development. Their racial classification changed throughout time as a result of economic and social mobility, allowing them to attend white institutions and schools while gradually isolating them from the Black community. 

Racial identity in the United States is complex, as demonstrated by this story; it is about more than just skin color; it is also about social position, economic status, and strategic adaptation. Learning about the Chinese in the Mississippi Delta allows us to better understand the difficulties of other oppressed groups as they attempt to overcome racial barriers, find their place in society, and adjust to new conditions. Their fortitude is a powerful emblem of the never-ending struggle for acceptance and opportunity in the United States. 

References: 

Banks, T. L. (1998). Both edges of the margin: Blacks and Asians in Mississippi Masala, barriers to coalition building. Asian Law Journal, 5, 7–27. 

Chang, I. (2004). The Chinese in America: A narrative history. Penguin. 

 

Cheng, L. C. (1974). The Chinese in Mississippi: An ethnic people in a biracial society. International Migration Review, 8(1), 65–77. 

Dong, Y. (2021). Sweet and sour: The representations of Chinese Americans in American popular culture, 2010-2020. Arkansas State University. 

Gillot-Assayag, L. (2016). Mae M. Ngai, Impossible Subjects: Illegal Aliens and the Making of Modern America. Transatlantica. Revue d’études américaines. American Studies Journal, (1). 

Jung, J. (2008). Chopsticks in The Land of Cotton: Lives of Mississippi Delta Chinese Grocers. Lulu.com. 

Lee, E. (2015). The making of Asian America: A history. Simon & Schuster. 

Loewen, J. W. (1988). The Mississippi Chinese: Between black and white. Waveland Press. 

McLemore, S. D., Romo, H., & Baker, S. G. (1980). Racial and ethnic relations in America. 

Reynolds, D. M. (2023). Why do teachers leave? Analyzing teacher retention and job satisfaction in the Mississippi Delta (Doctoral dissertation, Trident University International). 

Shin, J. H. (2014). In between: The Mississippi Chinese and the American racial structure. 미국학, 37(2), 81-109. 

Takaki, R. (2012). Strangers from a different shore: A history of Asian Americans (Updated and revised). eBookIt.com. 

Torok, J. H. (2005). Asian American jurisprudence: On curriculum. Mich. St. L. Rev., 635. 

Yang, H. (2021). Built for food: The resistance of Chinese immigrants from service to ownership, 1880–1960 (Doctoral dissertation, The University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee). 

Yu, S. (2022). Placing racial triangulation, triangulating place and race: Chinese grocery stores in the Mississippi Delta during the Jim Crow era. Annals of the American Association of Geographers, 112(1), 97-122. 

bottom of page